← Back to the conversation

Episode 02 · Companion article · Opinion & analysis

Whiskey,
Sour Politics.

The Texas Senate Race

September 24, 2026 10-minute read

The written companion to the forthcoming second episode of Grimm on the Rocks. The video will be added when it’s ready.

What conduct are you willing to accept to get the policies you want? Before you answer, how sure are you that you’ll get them?

My wife is from Michigan, and we recently moved from there back to my home state of Texas. We still spend a lot of time in Michigan, which means I get Senate campaign ads in two states, as if one wasn’t enough. One commercial says a candidate understands my struggles. The next says he threatens everything I care about. Right now, I’d settle for getting through the commercial break.

In Texas, the choice is Ken Paxton and James Talarico. I arrived with impressions of both: allegations about Paxton’s conduct, clips of Talarico sounding considerably more radical than his reassuring campaign presentation. But an impression is a starting point. It is not a checked record.

A whiskey sour seems appropriate. Let’s see what survives a closer look.

“Most corrupt” needs more than a bigger number

Talarico’s campaign ad “Most Corrupt” points to Paxton’s property holdings and impeachment, according to the Texas Tribune.1 That is quite a title to award in Texas. Former state senator Carlos Uresti received a twelve-year federal sentence in 2018 for his role in a Ponzi scheme.2 You don’t just walk in and take the belt.

Separate from the ad, consider two wealth figures: a reported household net worth of $5.4 million in 2015, and a Forbes estimate of about $13 million in 2026, reported by the Houston Chronicle.34

The arithmetic, with the assumptions

($13 million ÷ $5.4 million)1/11 − 1 ≈ 8.3% a year

This is my illustration, not a calculation attributed to the ad. It assumes comparable endpoints, eleven years, and no contributions or withdrawals. The figures come from different sources and methods. This is not an audited investment return or an explanation of how the Paxtons’ wealth actually grew.

If the argument is simply that the number got bigger, that’s a pretty stupid corruption argument. Show me an improper payment. Show me the favor. Compound growth is not a smoking gun.

But the calculation does not dispose of the disclosure questions. The Tribune and ProPublica reported omitted rental income and mortgages, along with questions about property valuations. Paxton’s campaign rejected the allegations and pointed to his private-sector career.3 Those issues deserve answers. Neither “he got richer” nor my arithmetic supplies them.

The impeachment also has an outcome: the Texas Senate acquitted Paxton on the articles it tried. The Tribune included that in its ad coverage.16 I can disagree with the senators. I still have to include their decision.

Different cases. Different answers.

There is a broader record behind my concerns about Paxton. At the impeachment trial, former chief of staff Missy Cary testified that he had acknowledged an affair and later said it was continuing; his lawyer challenged parts of her recollection and its relevance, the Tribune reported.5 The public-office issue was the allegation that he used his office to benefit donor Nate Paul, who employed the woman involved. Paxton denied wrongdoing.6

That history should not become one enormous, undifferentiated accusation. Here are the separate outcomes discussed in the episode.

The record, separated
ProceedingOutcomeKeep the distinction
2023 impeachmentSenate acquittal on the articles tried.6An accusation and an acquittal both belong in the account.
State securities prosecutionA 2024 pretrial agreement without admission of wrongdoing; dismissal reported in June 2025 after restitution of about $271,000 and other requirements.78Neither a conviction nor a case still awaiting trial.
Federal corruption investigationAP reported in April 2025 that federal prosecutors declined charges in the separate investigation involving Paul.9A reported prosecution decision, not a jury verdict.
Civil whistleblower litigationAn April 2025 judgment of more than $6 million against the attorney general’s office; appeal withdrawn that July, according to reporting.1011Office liability for retaliation, not a personal criminal bribery conviction.

The office had chosen not to contest liability and consented to judgment while continuing to reject the whistleblowers’ claims, as the Texas Supreme Court described in a discovery opinion. The Chronicle reported Paxton’s explanation that contesting the case would mean more expense and disruption.611

My judgment: that retaliation judgment is a serious public-trust problem. Agreeing with the man politically does not make it smaller. It makes it easier for me to look away.

I am choosing a senator. I don’t need a criminal conviction to decide someone has not earned my trust. But I cannot borrow the authority of a conviction that did not happen. The specific record gives me enough to demand an answer without awarding a statewide corruption championship.

An artificial opponent is not extra evidence

Now turn the television around. Paxton’s campaign used an AI-generated Talarico with a fictional Bible. FactCheck.org found that the ad combined actual remarks, missing context, and added phrases. It disclosed its use of AI.12

Fine. We know the man on screen isn’t real. What about what he is supposedly saying? You don’t get extra evidence by giving the accusation a face that moves.

The remark about hating Christianity came from a longer discussion that also described Talarico’s attachment to Jesus’s teachings, FactCheck reported. The ad’s scene about God announcing six genders was a campaign construction, not the original legislative exchange.12 You can question the real remarks without improving them into something he did not say.

WorldNetDaily’s September 8 coverage assured readers that the ad was “based upon his own actual statements all documented in the ad.” It acknowledged the AI and included critical reader reactions.24 But which words were his, which were added, and what did the editing change?

FactCheck’s examination appeared a week later. This is a comparison of how the material was handled, not an accusation that the earlier report ignored a future correction. Nor does one example establish how every newsroom works.

Finding a misleading attack on Talarico still leaves his own answers open to scrutiny.

The answer changed. What would the policy be?

In a 2021 hearing, Talarico described six biological sexes using chromosome combinations. In September 2026, he corrected that claim in a Fox interview: “There are not six sexes, there are two.”13

I want lawmakers invoking science to be careful. I also cannot demand corrections and then keep presenting the old answer as though no correction occurred.

The more useful policy question concerns his stated opposition to transition-related surgery for minors. He has pointed to support for a surgery-focused amendment.13 The legislative record supports that narrower point—and complicates the broader impression.

What the 2023 SB 14 record shows
ProposalWhat it would doTalarico’s vote
Amendment 13Remove medication restrictions while retaining surgical restrictions and specified exceptions.1415Yea · Record 1679. Failed.16
Amendment 7Allow an exception with a written gender-dysphoria diagnosis from two qualified professionals, each agreeing treatment or procedures were needed to prevent severe harm.Yea · Record 1673. Failed.16
Amendment 11His proposed exception where the restrictions conflicted with a provider’s compliance with the Hippocratic oath.18Yea · Record 1677. Failed.16
Amendment 12Exempt children diagnosed with gender dysphoria from the prohibitions, including surgical restrictions.19Yea · Record 1678. Failed.16
Final House passageThe final bill, with its multiple restrictions.Nay · Record 1688. Passed.17

These are historical votes and failed amendment proposals. The proposed exceptions in Amendments 7, 11, and 12 were broader than Amendment 13 and could reach surgical restrictions. The table does not describe current medical guidance or treat a compromise vote as a complete personal platform.

Opposing a bill with several provisions does not tell us his position on each provision. Supporting one narrower version does not erase the broader exceptions he also supported.

My question is simple: what restrictions would you support now, and what exceptions would you allow? “I oppose it” needs enough detail for us to know what “it” means.

I cannot tell from these votes whether his current explanation reflects reconsideration, compromise, or campaign positioning. They establish votes, not private motives. They do establish why the reassuring sentence needs a follow-up question.

A fairly important adjective to recover

CNN’s September 1 broadcast carried a 2020 forum excerpt linking capitalism, white supremacy, and climate change as oppressive systems to dismantle. It also carried the campaign’s description of Talarico as a capitalist.20 In a later NewsNation interview, he explained that he meant crony capitalism, according to the transcript published by NewsBusters.21

Well, that is a fairly important adjective to recover.

The excerpt uses the broader term. The later explanation narrows it. I have not reviewed the entire original forum, so I am not claiming that a few sentences settle everything he meant.

But I do find the rhetoric in that excerpt sloppy. It bundles an economic system, racism, and an environmental problem without explaining what would replace them or how. That makes me less confident in his judgment. The later explanation has not resolved that concern for me.

If you changed your mind, explain what changed it. If that was always your meaning, show where you made the distinction. And if an opponent calls you a socialist, I want the actual proposal behind the label. Government insurance, regulation, and government ownership are different things.

What would I actually get?

Paxton has advertised deductions for expenses including health-insurance premiums. Talarico proposes letting Americans of any age join Medicare alongside private insurance.2223 Now there are approaches we can question: who benefits, how much does it cost, who pays, and who is left out?

The Tribune described a Paxton ad portraying Talarico’s opposition to a Republican tax-and-spending package as support for taxes on tips and overtime. Talarico’s objections included cuts to assistance programs and the distribution of tax benefits.22 Opposing a package does not establish opposition to every provision. That distinction has to work for candidates I dislike, too.

Talarico, meanwhile, treated billionaire opposition as evidence he was on the right track.22 Having wealthy opponents establishes that you have wealthy opponents. It does not establish that your policy works.

My initial sense that Paxton would deliver predictable policies is an assumption to check. Talarico’s reassuring presentation is not a policy explanation. I want the explanation after the applause.

Equal standards can produce unequal conclusions

Maybe you have reservations and still think one of these men will vote the way you want. I understand. That is the bargain. But say what you are accepting, and identify the evidence for what you expect in return.

For Paxton, I take the retaliation judgment seriously while acknowledging the acquittal, dismissal, and reported decision not to prosecute. For Talarico, I reject the manufactured attack and acknowledge the correction, while questioning the legislative record and the gap between earlier rhetoric and current explanations.

I am not adding up scandals until the columns match. You do not have to turn your preferred candidate into a saint. I do not have to find these men equally objectionable to examine both.

Doing the homework may leave your vote unchanged. It should leave you able to explain the choice without needing inconvenient parts of the story to disappear.

And this is where I get irritated with the news business. CNN, the Tribune, and FactCheck did useful work here. We used it. But a voter can encounter an accusation repeatedly and never encounter the reporting that explains it. Making the context available somewhere is not the same as getting it in front of the people who heard the claim.

Come home, make dinner, put the kids to bed—and then go spelunking through the internet to discover which thirty seconds of television deserved your confidence? The campaign puts its version in front of you. The missing context becomes your homework.

I’m some jamoke living on a beach in Texas with a computer and a microphone. Tell me what was alleged, what was decided, and when the answer changed. Give me enough information to make up my own damn mind. If I leave out the part that complicates my argument, hold me to that too.

You earn trust by showing your work. And this jamoke with a microphone owes you exactly the same thing.

Follow the evidence

Sources & notes

Adapted for reading from Episode 2, script Draft 0.8. This is opinion and analysis of a selected record as of September 24, 2026, not a comprehensive candidate assessment. Court and legislative documents are distinguished below from attributed reporting, interview transcripts, and campaign claims. Personal judgments and the wealth calculation are the author’s.

The original full 2020 forum, interview and ad playbacks, and final securities-dismissal and civil-damages orders have not been independently reviewed for this article. Quotations from interviews rely on the identified transcripts. No claim is made about the present payment balance of the civil judgment.

  1. Texas Tribune: Talarico’s “Most Corrupt” ad ↗

    August 29, 2026. Reporting on the campaign ad and its property/impeachment argument; includes the acquittal. The article’s wealth calculation is separate from the ad.

  2. U.S. Department of Justice: Uresti sentencing ↗

    June 26, 2018. Historical sentencing announcement concerning the FourWinds Ponzi scheme, not a claim about current incarceration or an objective corruption ranking.

  3. Texas Tribune / ProPublica: Paxton’s financial disclosures ↗

    September 4, 2026. Reports the $5.4 million household figure for 2015 and questions concerning rental income, mortgages, and valuations; includes the campaign’s response. Underlying finances were not independently audited here.

  4. Houston Chronicle: Paxton wealth estimate ↗

    August 24, 2026. Reports Forbes’s approximately $13 million estimate, with information gaps. The two wealth figures have different methods; 8.3% is an illustrative annual compound rate, not an observed return.

  5. Texas Tribune: Cary’s impeachment-trial testimony ↗

    September 11, 2023. Reporting on testimony and the defense’s challenge, rather than an independent review of the hearing footage.

  6. Texas Supreme Court: In re OAG, No. 24-0073 (PDF) ↗

    Official opinion describing the litigation, impeachment outcome, consent to judgment, and continued denial. This is a discovery opinion, not the final damages order.

  7. Texas Tribune: Securities-case agreement ↗

    March 26, 2024. Agreement and conditions without an admission of wrongdoing. Read alongside the subsequent dismissal report.

  8. Bloomberg Law: Securities charges dismissed ↗

    June 18, 2025. Reports dismissal after restitution, service, and ethics training; the original dismissal order was not independently obtained.

  9. Associated Press: Federal prosecutors declined charges ↗

    April 3, 2025. Attributed reporting on the federal investigation involving Paul, not a public declination letter or a jury verdict.

  10. Texas Tribune: Whistleblower judgment ↗

    April 4, 2025. Reports an award of approximately $6.6 million against the office under the Texas Whistleblower Act.

  11. Houston Chronicle: Appeal withdrawn ↗

    July 3, 2025. Reports withdrawal and the earlier expense-and-disruption rationale for not contesting the case.

  12. FactCheck.org: Paxton’s AI ad and omitted context ↗

    September 15, 2026. Published comparison of the ad with prior remarks. This article relies on that examination and does not claim an independent audiovisual comparison.

  13. NewsBusters: Fox interview transcript ↗

    September 9, 2026. Third-party transcript for the correction and surgery answer. Its editorial framing is not adopted as fact; original audio remains unchecked.

  14. SB 14: House committee report (PDF) ↗

    2023 bill text. Read pages 2–4 with the amendment language; references concern historical proposals, not medical advice.

  15. SB 14: Amendment 13 ↗

    Proposed removal of medication restrictions, retaining surgical restrictions and specified exceptions. Its vote is recorded in source 16.

  16. Texas House Journal: May 12, 2023 (PDF) ↗

    Amendment 7: Record 1673, printed pp. 4199–4200; Amendment 11: Record 1677, p. 4204; Amendment 12: Record 1678, p. 4205; Amendment 13: Record 1679, pp. 4206–4207. Talarico voted Yea on each; each failed. Amendment 7 specifies two qualified professionals and prevention of severe physical, emotional, or psychological harm.

  17. Texas House Journal: May 15, 2023 (PDF) ↗

    Record 1688, printed pp. 4242–4243: final House passage of SB 14, with Talarico voting Nay.

  18. SB 14: Talarico’s Amendment 11 ↗

    Proposed Hippocratic-oath exception. The text, not the amendment’s name alone, supports the description of its scope.

  19. SB 14: Amendment 12 ↗

    Proposed diagnosis-based exception to the prohibitions; read with the underlying committee bill in source 14.

  20. CNN: September 1 broadcast transcript ↗

    KFILE segment beginning around 19:47. Contains the 2020 forum excerpt and the campaign’s response; it is not the complete original forum.

  21. NewsBusters: NewsNation interview transcript ↗

    September 10, 2026. Source for the later crony-capitalism explanation; a third-party transcript, not an original-audio check.

  22. Texas Tribune: Paxton ads and Talarico’s response ↗

    September 15, 2026. Reported deductions proposal, tax-package attack, stated objections, and billionaire-opposition argument. Does not independently establish policy costs or effects.

  23. Talarico campaign: Health Care ↗

    Campaign position accessed September 24, 2026. Establishes the stated Medicare proposal; the campaign’s predictions about its effects are not treated as independent findings.

  24. WorldNetDaily: Coverage of Paxton’s AI ad ↗

    Joe Kovacs, September 8, 2026. The assurance about documented statements is distinguished from reader comments. Publication preceded FactCheck’s September 15 examination.

Room to be wrong

Corrections & updates

Found a factual error or a source we should consider? Message Grimm on the Rocks on Instagram ↗ with the article title, the passage, and a link to the evidence. Sign-in may be required.

September 24, 2026 · Opening updated

Adapted from Episode 2, Draft 0.8, with a shorter written opening, separate legal-outcome and legislative-vote tables, linked source notes, and explicit limits on the wealth illustration. Opening subsequently clarified to identify the author’s family connection to Michigan and recent move back to his home state of Texas. The argument is unchanged. Substantive corrections will be recorded here with the date and their effect on the argument.

The first pour

How the story gets sold.

The first article looks at persuasion, missing context, and the assumptions we bring to the evidence.

Read An Old Fashioned Lie →